History of the Congregational Church of Jefferson Park
An 1884 history described the church this way:
The Jefferson Congregational Church was organized in April, 1861. with seven members, who united by letter. Among them were Mr. and Mrs. David L. Roberts, Mr. and Mrs. Orton Hubbard,and Reuben Bailey. Two or three weeks afterward nine members joined on profession of faith, among them Miss Ellen O. Roberts and Miss Lydia Main. Previously to the organization there had been religious service held by Rev. Lemuel Jones, in the school-house and in the Town House, in which latter building the organization was effected. Rev. Mr. Jones remained until the last of August, 1863.
During his pastorate, in the summer and fall of 1861, the church building was erected, a frame structure costing about $1,500. It was dedicated soon after its completion, Prof. S. C. Bartlett preaching the sermon. A parsonage was built in 1863, on a lot donated to the Church by David L. Roberts, as was also the church. The society received no aid during Rev. Mr. Jones’s pastorate, and the seats were free until the pastorate of Rev. J. M. Williams. The Church was re-organized February 24, 1866, when a constitution and by-laws were adopted. The deacons elected at this time were E. S. Dunning and Orton Hubbard, and the trustees in 1869 were D. S. Dunning, J. H. Wright and W.C. Hazleton. In 1866 the Church received three hundred dollars from the Home Missionary Society. In 1867 the support of the pastor was again assumed ; and in 1868 the pastor was engaged at $800 per year. Rev. M. Smith succeeded Mr. Jones, and remained until 1866, when the Rev. E. C. Barnard was engaged, and remained until 1871. He was succeeded by Rev. M. N. Hall, who remained until 1873, when Rev. Mr. Barnard became pastor of the Church, at a salary of $1,000 per year. He remained until 1879, when Rev. J. M. Williams succeeded and remained until 1882. In this latter year Rev. W.D. Simons, the present pastor, succeeded Rev. Mr. Williams. Late in the year 1883 repairs to the extent of about $400 were made to the church, and the building was re-dedicated on Sunday, December 3 of that year.